Neti

This project is not actively maintained. Proceed at your own risk!

Neti firewall sync service for EC2-VPC migration

Requirements

Currently, Neti works on Ubuntu/Debian, but should work on many more platforms with a few tweaks to the package management. Also, if you don't use AWS, you can just stop reading now...not even sure how you got here. You'll need a set of AWS keys that allows instance metadata modification. You will need to create a Zookeeper cluster, so familiarity with Zookeeper is necessary, but all that is needed is a very basic installation.

Building Neti

Neti is buildable as a pip package.

Deploying and Using Neti

Neti should be installed using a configuration management solution like Chef. In fact, there is also neti-cookbook which you can use as a template to install Neti in your infrastructure.

Neti is provided as-is, and, while it worked wonders for Instagram's EC2-VPC migration, it is tailored for our use, and may not work for you without a number of tweaks. Here are some of the major considerations for making this work in your infrastructure:

Prerequisites/Assumptions

Security groups

Neti works best with a relatively flat security group architecture. This doesn't mean that it can't work with a complex architecture, but the main mechanism of Neti opens up communication channels between all of your hosts on EC2 and VPC. Neti, in conjunction with Neti-cookbook can give full control over which ports should be open to the public Internet on each instance/instance type (using open_ports in the config), but if you need more control in terms of which other security groups can access these ports, you'll need to use AWS security groups on top of that, and the configuration might get messy.

Safeguards

You can define a set of IP ranges from which SSH is always allowed, which makes sure that if anything screws up in the rule tables you will (most likely) be able to still get into the instances with SSH. (We never had to fall back on this during our migration, but we kept a few options open at all times in case the worst happened).

Zookeeper

As mentioned above, you need to be able to bring up a Zookeeper cluster in VPC for this to work. Defaults on the cluster should be fine. You will turn up this cluster in VPC, and then use the Neti-cookbook's zkneti recipe to bring up an identical number of hosts in EC2, which will proxy all zookeeper requests to the cluster in VPC. Both of these clusters must NOT run Neti, and must have their own security groups on either side. These clusters should have Elastic IPs assigned to them, and these EIPs must be configured on both sides to allow Zookeeper traffic from the other side. There's a helper script (scripts/update_zkneti_groups.py) that will set this for you, as long as you fill in the necessary data about the security groups on both sides once the hosts are alive.

You have complete control over the node naming in Zookeeper, but leaving the defaults should work just fine.

You will need to enter in both the EC2 and VPC host IPs and ports for the clusters into the neti.yml config, under zk_hosts.

Addressing

The overlay subnet is defaulted to 192.168.0.0/18. This won't conflict with your EC2 addresses, as they will be in the 10.0.0.0/8 range, and you must make sure that the subnets you configure on the VPC side do not overlap with this subnet either.

In the case that you have some NATs defined on certain hosts already, and you don't want Neti to overwrite them with its own rules, you can add them using the nat_overrides parameter in the config file, which just takes a hash of source: dest IPs.

VPC Quirks

When you create instances in VPC, you will need to give every one of them a public interface. This is a flag, known as "Auto-assign Public IP" in the AWS console, and :associate_public_ip in knife-ec2. You cannot add these interfaces after creating the instances, so make sure your tools for creating instances are configured to set this flag. Also, make sure that the tools you use support it. For example, knife-ec2 has to be at least v0.8.0 for support.

Procedure

Here is a rough list of what you need to do to get Neti up and running:

• Build VPC. This is going to be configured differently for everyone.
• Build ZK cluster and ZKNeti Proxy cluster
  • Create them with associated Elastic IPs in different security groups
  • Run scripts/update_zkneti_groups.py to sync their rules
• Build Neti installation and configuration into your configuration management infra
  • Again, this is difficult to define, as everyone's going to have different setups. The one that worked for us was using pip to install Neti, and configuring using Chef. We added Neti into our base role (after testing on a few hosts, of course).
• Test
• Test
• Test some more
• Bring up Neti on your entire EC2 infra, making sure to keep the reject_all flag in the config set to False. This should allow your entire infrastructure to operate without any changes. Your AWS security groups are still in place. All that's happening at this point is that all the hosts are registered with Neti, and all should be accessible using their overlay IPs. TEST THAT THIS IS TRUE.
• Convert your DB/app/cache/etc configuration scripts to use overlay IPs. If you autogenerate your configs, then you'll be happy! If not, this is a good time to start.
• Bring up a few test hosts in the VPC and verify that they register correctly.
• Use scripts/neti_util.py to your benefit...it will tell you what is left in your infra that isn't running Neti.
• Turn reject_all to True on a single host. If it still can connect to everything it's supposed to, things are going well.
• Slowly roll out the reject_all = True change across your infrastructure...test with each tier, etc. Be careful.
• Once Neti is running everywhere, scripts/neti_util.py runs clean, and reject_all is enabled everywhere, change your security groups to allow all access from any AWS IP range. The scripts/ip_ranges.py tool is useful for this.
• At this point, here is the state of things:
  • Neti knows about all of your instances in both EC2 and VPC.
  • Each instance has specific access rules allowing communication from every other host to it.
  • IPtables is rejecting everything else, except from the ports in open_ports.
  • All traffic to your instances from any other IP in the public AWS-owned ranges is allowed in, but gets blocked at IPtables.
  • You should finally be able to communicate between your hosts in VPC and those in EC2.
• You're "done"...now you can actually do the migration.

Testing

Use nosetests to run the tests in the tests directory. They're basic tests, but they cover the main functionality. Please know that tests passing does not mean that you can inadequately test in your environment! These tests only make sure that Neti registers and builds things correctly...they don't and can't make sure that it opens that port you forgot Nginx listens on.

How Neti works

See the blog post

See the CONTRIBUTING file for how to help out.

License

Neti is BSD-licensed. We also provide an additional patent grant.